The Walking Dead Chitty-Chat Club: SHOOT HIM, SHOOT HIM, SHOOT HIM!!!

A stranger approaches Rick's Rangers with a deal they might not be able to refuse. Should they go with him, or SHOOT HIM, SHOOT HIM, SHOOT HIM??? (I think you know what my answer will be... but I want to hear your opinion about last night's episode of The Walking Dead. Hit the jump for my spoiler-filled recap and let's get chitty-chatting!)
Courtesy AMC"Hi guys. One question: Have you accepted Jesus Christ as your lord and...OH GOD DON'T SHOOT MEEEEE!!!"
MORE AFTER THE JUMP!