Kane Brown Reveals His Less-Than-Romantic Proposal: ‘I Just Couldn’t Wait’

Does Kane Brown need a little help in the romance department?
He reveals to PEOPLE that he popped the question to girlfriend Katelyn Jae one night in April while the two were watching The Amityville Horror, a movie about newlyweds who move into a house where a mass murder has been committed.
Um, let’s just hope Brown doesn’t believe in omens.
Brown, the 24-year-old up-and-comer who just notched a No. 1 with “What Ifs” with childhood pal Lauren Alaina, admits it